Seven Reasons for Christian Belief (click to view)
As bulletin articles are necessarily sketchy, the following link permits a more detailed engagement along these lines:
God: The Best Explanation by Paul Copan (See especially the Worldview Chart pages 103–104 in the chapter)
For those seeking a more academic, scholarly level engagement: please enjoy the articles in The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology (2009) edited by William Lane Craig and J.P. Moreland.
Most of all, Pontius Pilate’s situational question is everyone’s question: What will I do with Jesus? For those grappling with Jesus in Historical context, two helpful, competent, and open-minded scholars writing in this area are N.T. Wright and Ben Witherington. And of course, there is nothing like reading the Gospels.